Easy Cinnamon French Toast Sticks

Introduction

The morning I fell in love with Cinnamon French Toast Sticks started as a disaster and ended with sticky fingers and a silent kitchen because everyone was too busy dunking and munching. It was one of those cozy, gray Saturdays where the light is soft, the windows fog just a bit, and the whole house smells like melted butter and cinnamon. I was still half-asleep, hair in a chaotic bun, humming to keep my eyes open while the skillet warmed. Honestly, I wasn’t aiming for greatness—just breakfast that didn’t involve cereal or bribery.

I grabbed brioche, sliced it thick, and told myself I’d make “real” French toast. Then I realized I’d promised my niece “dippable sticks like the ones on TV,” so I pivoted—scissor-cut rectangles, quick whisked custard, and away we went. First batch? I soaked the bread too long. Oops. Sog city. The second batch hit the butter with a polite sizzle, edges crisping while the centers puffed like little pillows. The smell—oh my—warm cinnamon, toasty vanilla, a hit of sugar that caramelized in spots and left gold freckles across the surface.

By the time I rolled those warm sticks through cinnamon-sugar, they wore a sparkly coat like sandy beach pebbles. We dunked them in maple syrup, and I swear the sound of the crust cracking under our teeth could’ve been a commercial. Soft inside. Crispy outside. Sweet but not cloying. And because they’re finger food, they feel playful—great for kids, honestly great for adults, and perfect for quick family meals when you want to be the hero without a heroic effort.

To be real, these sticks may be the most adaptable little breakfast I make. They freeze like a dream, reheat in minutes for meal prep microwave lunches, and slide easily into a weekend lineup of budget-friendly recipes. If you’re balancing a protein meal plan, pair them with turkey sausage or scrambled eggs to nudge your macros. If you’re into healthy eating for two or hunting for best meals to prep, this recipe belongs in your back pocket. Weekend brunch, weekday snack, or dessert disguised as breakfast—your kitchen, your rules. And yes, they count as healthy comfort food when you eat them slowly with coffee and fruit. That’s my story and I’m sticking to it.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

• Hand-held happiness. These are dip-and-go sticks, perfect for small hands, car breakfasts, or lazy couch mornings.
• Texture goals. Shatter-crisp edges outside, custardy-soft inside—the contrast is everything.
• Customizable to your mood. A whisper of nutmeg, a little orange zest, or a drizzle of chocolate? Go wild.
• Freezer-friendly. Make once, enjoy all week. Ten minutes to hot breakfast beats hunting for ready made protein meals any day.
• Crowd-pleaser. Kids cheer, adults ask for seconds, and that cinnamon-sugar scent makes the whole house feel like a bakery.
• Plays well with plans. Pair with eggs or yogurt to support high macro meals and a reasonable protein eating plan without losing the fun.

What Makes This Recipe Special?

Cinnamon toast sticks sound simple—and they are—but the method is why these hit different. I start with thick-cut bread (Texas toast or brioche) that’s a little stale so it drinks the custard without collapsing. The custard is eggy and gently sweet with vanilla, and I keep the dip quick—just a roll, not a soak—so the sticks stay structured. Butter in a hot pan does the rest, giving those edges a buttery crisp that crackles when you bite.

Right off the skillet, the sticks get rolled in cinnamon-sugar so the warmth melts the crystals just enough to cling. The finish is nostalgic and bakery-level at the same time. Plus, the recipe flexes like a yoga teacher. Bake them when you need hands-off. Air fry when you want speed. Freeze a batch for the kind of mornings when best dinner prep meals accidentally became “we forgot to prep anything at all.” These are the ultimate “I didn’t expect that” breakfast win.

Ingredients

Save

• Thick-cut bread (Texas toast or brioche)
• Large eggs
• Milk (whole or 2%)
• Vanilla extract
• Ground cinnamon
• Granulated sugar
• Unsalted butter (or neutral oil)
• Pinch of salt
• Maple syrup for dipping

Why each ingredient matters

Thick bread is your foundation. Day-old slices are slightly drier, which means they soak just enough custard to be fluffy inside without turning to mush. Eggs are structure and richness; they set into a soft custard inside each stick. Milk keeps the custard light and pourable—whole milk tastes luxurious, but 2% works when you want to lean toward low fat meal delivery vibes at home. Vanilla is the warm back note that makes everything taste “bakery.” Cinnamon dances in both the custard and the sugar coating; it’s breakfast perfume.

Sugar does double duty—just a touch in the custard for browning, more in the coating for sparkle and crunch. Butter equals flavor but also crispy magic. Salt is the invisible hero that makes sweet flavors pop and keeps things from tasting one-note. Maple syrup is optional because the sticks already shine, but that dunk is…well, it’s the hug at the end of the story.

My tips, brand notes, and swaps

Brioche gives buttery richness; Texas toast gives sturdiness and height. Use what you love. If dairy isn’t your friend, use a rich, unsweetened plant milk. For the coating, a mix of granulated and superfine sugar clings beautifully. If you want an extra-thick cinnamon-sugar jacket, double-dip: once right off the pan, once again just before serving.

Don’t do this

Don’t soak the sticks like you would classic French toast slices—quick dips are the move. Don’t crowd the pan or the edges steam instead of crisp. Don’t skip the salt; it’s tiny but mighty. And don’t wander off to “fold laundry” while batch two is cooking; cinnamon-sugar goes from caramelized to burnt faster than we expect. Been there. Deeply regretted it.

How to Make It Step-by-Step

1) Prep the bread

I trim crusts when I’m aiming for “uniform sticks that stack like Lincoln Logs,” but you can keep them for extra crunch. Slice each piece into three or four chunky sticks. If the bread is super soft, I lay the slices on a rack for 10 minutes to air-dry. They should feel just a bit firm.

2) Build the custard

In a shallow dish, I whisk eggs, milk, vanilla, cinnamon, a spoon of sugar, and a pinch of salt. The color turns a warm latte shade, and it smells like the inside of a bakery box. Pro tip: whisk more than you think you need to break up the whites so they coat evenly.

3) Make the cinnamon-sugar

On a plate, I stir granulated sugar with more cinnamon. The ratio is yours to choose—more cinnamon for big spice energy, more sugar for extra sparkle. I like 1 tablespoon cinnamon per ¼ cup sugar, sometimes with a whisper of nutmeg.

4) Dip like you mean it, but quickly

Each stick gets a fast bath—roll, roll, lift. No lingering. I let excess drip back into the dish so we don’t carry extra moisture to the pan. The goal? Custard-kissed, not swamped.

5) Sizzle time

I heat a large nonstick skillet over medium to medium-high. A pat of butter melts into a glossy puddle and starts to smell nutty. The sticks go in with a soft hiss, lined up like cinnamon soldiers. I cook two to three minutes per side, rolling to toast the edges. They pick up caramel spots, the surface gets matte, and the house smells like a holiday morning.

6) Coat while warm

Straight from the skillet, the sticks go into cinnamon-sugar. The warmth softens the sugar just enough to cling without melting off. I roll them gently, tapping off loose crystals, and transfer to a rack so the bottoms don’t steam.

7) Serve and dunk

I pile them on a plate, add a little pitcher of warm maple syrup, and watch the dunking begin. The first bite is crisp at the edges, custardy inside, with a happy cinnamon snap. It’s the kind of bite that makes you close your eyes for a second and nod to no one.

8) Alternate paths

Baked version? Spread on a greased sheet and bake at 350°F, 10 minutes per side, until golden. Air fryer? 375°F for 6–8 minutes, flipping halfway. These methods are perfect for best meal prep plans and those mornings when the stovetop is busy with eggs or meal planning chicken for the week.

Mistakes I’ve made and what they taught me

I once used fresh-from-the-bakery brioche that was dangerously soft. Soaked it like a spa day. The result was…pudding sticks. Tasty, but floppy. Lesson: use sturdier slices or let them dry first. I’ve also burned a batch by wandering off to “quickly” answer a text. Cinnamon-sugar punishes daydreamers. And when I skipped the post-cook sugar roll, my family mutinied. The sparkle isn’t optional in this house.

Tips for Best Results

Use day-old or lightly dried bread for structural integrity. Preheat the skillet and don’t be shy with butter—fat conducts heat for that golden crust. Work in batches and keep finished sticks on a rack so they stay crisp. If you need to hold them, pop the rack onto a sheet and keep in a 250°F oven for up to 20 minutes.

Flavor boosters? A pinch of orange zest in the custard, or swap vanilla for almond extract on holidays. For more crunch, mix a tablespoon of turbinado sugar into the coating. For macro balance on high protein meals days, serve with Greek yogurt and berries or scrambled eggs. It’s the easiest way to turn a sweet breakfast into part of your protein meal plan without sacrificing joy.

Ingredient Substitutions & Variations

Go dairy-free with almond or oat milk and plant butter. Make it gluten-free using a sturdy gluten-free loaf (toast slices briefly before dipping). For a cozy fall vibe, stir pumpkin pie spice into the sugar and dunk in warm apple butter. Want a vegan meal prep plan twist? Use your favorite egg replacer; aim a bit drier on the custard so the sticks still crisp.

For chocolate lovers, dust the warm sticks with a cocoa-cinnamon mix and serve with a thin chocolate sauce. To sneak in extra protein for high protein pre made meals energy, whisk a spoonful of vanilla protein powder into the custard and loosen with milk as needed. Looking for best vegan meal prep? Bake instead of pan-fry and use coconut sugar for a deeper caramel note.

Serving Suggestions

Save

Serve with a bowl of berries and a dollop of yogurt for color and freshness. For brunch crowds, add soft-scrambled eggs, turkey sausage, or chicken apple sausage to shift the plate toward high protein high carb low fat meals. For date-morning energy, dust the sticks with powdered sugar and serve with cinnamon latte and sliced oranges. If you’re building a spread, a platter of French toast sticks next to a fruit salad basically screams weekend happiness and works beautifully for healthy meal plans for two.

Pairing Ideas (Drinks, Sides, etc.)

• Drinks: Hot coffee, cold brew, chai, or a vanilla oat-milk latte. For summer, iced tea with lemon.
• Sides: Greek yogurt parfaits, turkey bacon, chicken sausage patties, or a light spinach omelet to lean into high carb high protein low fat meals.
• Extras: Warm maple syrup, strawberry compote, honey, or a swipe of peanut butter for that PB-and-maple moment.

How to Store and Reheat Leftovers

Cool completely and store in an airtight container in the fridge up to 3 days. For longer storage, freeze in a single layer on a sheet pan, then bag. Reheat from chilled in a 350°F oven for 6–8 minutes or pop in a toaster oven until hot and crisp. From frozen, add a few minutes. The air fryer is clutch here—375°F for about 4–6 minutes, and they taste freshly made. Avoid microwaving unless you like soft results; the edges lose their snap.

Make-Ahead and Freezer Tips

Batch-cook on Sunday for the week. Freeze the cooked sticks and you’ve basically created your own version of best high protein frozen meals—only better and more affordable. In the morning, reheat a few alongside scrambled eggs and fruit. It fits neatly into best meals to prep, good meal prep plans, and even no prep healthy lunches if you pack a small maple syrup cup and sliced fruit.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Over-soaking the bread: Quick dips keep the centers plush without collapse.
• Crowding the pan: They need space to crisp. Work in batches.
• Skipping the rack: Parking them on a plate steams the bottoms.
• Too-low heat: You’ll dry them out before they brown. Medium to medium-high is the sweet spot.
• Forgetting the salt: A pinch matters; it wakes up the cinnamon and vanilla.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Can I use regular sandwich bread?
Yes, but thick-cut bread holds up better. If using regular slices, dry them out in a low oven for 5–7 minutes before dipping.

How do I keep the bread from getting soggy?
Use day-old bread, dip quickly, and cook in a properly heated pan with enough butter to brown without drowning.

Is removing the crust necessary?
Nope. It’s a texture choice. Crusts add crisp edges; trimmed sticks look more uniform for photos.

Can I make these ahead of time?
Absolutely. Cook, cool, and freeze in a single layer. Reheat in the oven, toaster oven, or air fryer until crisp.

What can I serve with these?
Fresh fruit, yogurt, eggs, turkey sausage, or chicken sausage. For a brunch board, add berries, compotes, and a small bowl of nuts for crunch.

Can I make this dairy-free?
Yes—use plant milk and plant butter. If your milk is very thin, stir in a teaspoon of cornstarch to the custard for body.

How can I make the sticks extra crispy?
Preheat the skillet, don’t overcrowd, use a metal rack after cooking, and finish with a quick toast in the oven if needed.

Can I reduce the sugar?
Sure. Cut the cinnamon-sugar in half, skip the in-custard sugar, or drizzle a little honey instead of syrup.

Are these good for toddlers?
They’re great finger food. Cut smaller, watch for hot syrup, and supervise as always.

Can I add a filling?
Spread a thin layer of jam or nut butter between two slices, press gently, then cut and dip. Keep the layer thin so the sticks still crisp.

Cooking Tools You’ll Need

• Large nonstick skillet or griddle
• Mixing bowl and shallow dish
• Whisk and tongs
• Cooling rack set over a sheet pan
• Measuring cups and spoons
• Knife or kitchen scissors for cutting sticks

Final Thoughts

There’s a special kind of quiet that happens when a plate of Cinnamon French Toast Sticks hits the table. It’s the silence of happy dunking, of syrup threads stretching from plate to mouth, of cinnamon sugar dusting fingertips that no one bothers to wipe just yet. These aren’t fussy or precious. They’re familiar, playful, and forgiving. They invite improvisation. They’ve rescued more than one chaotic morning in my kitchen and become a weekend ritual that even my sleepiest people will tumble out of bed for.

If you love easy weeknight dinners, you’ll love how easily these turn into dessert-for-dinner with fruit on the side. If you’re steering through a hello fresh low calorie menu vibe during the week, serve a modest portion with eggs and berries and it still fits your rhythm. Most of all, they taste like a good mood—crisp, warm, cinnamon-loud, and dunk-happy.

If you enjoyed this recipe, don’t forget to save it on Pinterest or share it with a friend!